Skip to content

ScreenGawk

Where to Start With Dolly Parton’s Heartstrings

Prefer ScreenGawk on GoogleSee more of our stories in your results
Dolly Parton sings on stage during a Grand Ole Opry broadcast
Dolly Parton performs during a Grand Ole Opry broadcast in Nashville in 2005. Credit: Tech. Sgt. Cherie A. Thurlby / U.S. Air Force (public domain). Original photo · License

Three starting points

Before the premiere, Dolly Parton told Entertainment Tonight that she wrote a duet for herself and Julianne Hough to sing in a club scene in “Jolene.” Start with Jolene if you want a present-day story about friendship. Start with J.J. Sneed if you want a western that follows Maddie Hawkins, a sharpshooter, and an outlaw. Start with These Old Bones if you want a story about seeing and believing. Netflix’s setup introduces a mountain woman and a lawyer.

Parton’s site introduces the anthology as eight films, each based on one of her songs. Choose the story you want first and then check how much time it needs. Netflix lists “Jolene,” the present-day friendship story, at 67 minutes. “J.J. Sneed” is an Old West story and takes 56 minutes. “These Old Bones,” with a mountain woman stepping into the spotlight while a lawyer tries to find her voice, takes 85 minutes. The three stories make different demands on an evening. A short running time is useful if two premises sound equally good to you.

Jolene: a friendship tied to a song

Netflix describes Jolene as a modern take on the character's reputation, and Entertainment Tonight described the episode in 2019 as an unexpected friendship between different women who find themselves part of the song's love triangle. Hough plays Jolene. Kimberly Williams-Paisley and Dallas Roberts also appear, and Parton plays a character named Babe.

Exterior of the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum
The Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum in Nashville, photographed in 2013. Credit: Karakorhummel / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0, resized). · Original photo · License

Parton told Entertainment Tonight she wanted a Jolene who matched the song's description, with auburn hair, ivory skin and green eyes, and that Hough had all of it once the red hair went on. Parton said the duet came easily, that the two voices blended, and that she did not think Hough was too conscious of singing with her. A duet gives an edit two options: hold on both faces so you see them listen, or cut between them and treat each verse as a turn. Neither is automatically better.

If the club duet is what brings you to “Jolene,” choose one singer to watch and see whether the camera stays with her while the other sings. That is a different question from whether you like their voices together. The way an episode edits a performance can decide whose reaction you see, who gets a line to herself, and how long a singer holds the room. Do you follow the person singing, or see what it does to the person listening?

J.J. Sneed: a western built on a complicated bond

Netflix places J.J. Sneed in the Old West and calls it action-packed, centered on the sharpshooter Maddie Hawkins, the outlaw J.J. Sneed, and a complex bond between them in the face of chaos. The description gives you a genre, two roles, and a relationship that is not simple.

Westerns come with a visual grammar that a viewer can learn to notice. A sharpshooter makes distance a visible quantity: a wide frame shows how far a shot has to travel, and a close-up shows what it costs the person taking it. An outlaw story usually sets its lead against open space, a sky or a street, so the composition does part of the characterization before anyone speaks. That is genre convention, not a description of this episode, and the film may follow it or break it. The useful test is whether the staging gives the bond something to do. As a matter of taste, two people who must trust each other across a distance are more interesting than two people merely standing at either end of one.

Here the question is: does the film build Maddie's bond with the outlaw out of what the two do in the same space, or does it lean on the genre's familiar poses to stand in for feeling? Formal ambition can carry a story that is hard to care about, because a well-built set piece is satisfying even when the people in it are thin. It cannot make the bond complicated. That has to come from the performances. Skip this one if you want a quiet evening; Netflix's own word for it is action-packed.

These Old Bones: a story about being seen

Netflix summarizes “These Old Bones” as a story about seeing and believing. A mysterious mountain woman steps into the spotlight, and a lawyer struggles to find her voice. That gives you two places to direct your attention. When the mountain woman appears, pay attention to how much the camera lets you see. When the lawyer speaks, listen for where she seems sure of what she wants to say. A character can find a voice through the choices she makes, whether or not those choices change the way she sounds.

The stage and seating at the Ryman Auditorium
The Ryman Auditorium in Nashville, viewed from the balcony in 2015. Credit: Zpb52 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0, resized). · Original photo · License

If the lawyer’s struggle comes out in her delivery, notice whether the edit lets a pause sit. You can also follow the mountain woman, whose step into the spotlight is part of Netflix’s premise. If she draws your eye first, try one concrete question. How close does the camera bring you to her? You may read more from a face when you can see it clearly, but you may learn something different from a little more distance and the people within it.

Save “These Old Bones” for a night when you have about an hour and a half. It is the longest of the three by Netflix’s listing. If you only have an hour, “J.J. Sneed” fits without a break. The running time answers one part of the decision. The mountain story is still the one to choose if you want to see how an episode brings a person you know little about into view and have the time to stay with it.

How to choose

Pick by the kind of story you want and let the running time settle a tie. If the friendship story and western both appeal and you only have an hour, try “J.J. Sneed.” If you came because of the familiar song, make time for “Jolene.” After the first episode, think of a moment you wanted to see again. Was it the performance, the framing or the cut that brought you back? That gives you a way to decide what kind of episode you want to watch next.

Next related article